We’ve all heard the saying from the Oracle: "Be fearful when others are greedy, and greedy when others are fearful." There certainly seems to be some truth to that. I’ve always been somewhat of a contrarian, and as such have seen a few cycles come and go over the last couple of decades, missing huge opportunities more than once.
Of course the instinctual reaction to the current economic environment is to compare it to something historical. The South Sea Bubble of 1720. The Panic of 1873. The Great Depression. This Fourth of July weekend, I decided to re-read Michael Lewis’ "Liars Poker," having just finished reading "Too Big to Fail" (twice). I had forgotten the rules of Liar’s Poker, the gambling game that was played by the Solomon bond traders back in the mid-1980s. As I was reading, it struck me that the inherent bluffing that went on during a game of Liar’s Poker is similar to what is going on in the broader markets (equities in particular) today. It seems to me that the so-called smart money knows that the equity markets are about to have a significant sell-off, but it also knows it has front row seats to the show. Some investors are confident that they can reach the exit before panic really sets in with the less-connected and less-informed. Now the contrarian in me would normally see this as an opportunity to plant the seeds of future growth, as everyone runs around fearful. But a few things I’ve observed recently tell me that this is probably not the case.
First of all, the commercial world has developed multiple personalities when it comes to the credit crisis. On one hand, you have large business associations saying that the decrease in lending is simply a matter of decreased demand. On the other, you have large financial institutions advertising that they are lending more than ever. And finally, you have the widespread belief that credit is still relatively frozen, particularly for small and midsize businesses (SMBs), coupled with the notion that we are living in a "new normal" era of credit availability, where access to credit will not return to pre-crisis levels anytime soon. Which one are you supposed to believe? Well if you watch the television commercials, credit is flowing just like the good old days. But if you sit at my desk every day, you realize that this simply cannot be true. At The Receivables Exchange, we speak to literally thousands of small and medium companies every week, most of them businesses in need of working capital for growth. And the story I hear from them is not one of efficient capital availability for SMBs. I hear the story of stringent covenants, personal guarantees, revolver balance minimums and prolonged underwriting processes –- often up to 90 days. Basically, a testament to the adage of "capital is available to all companies without a capital need."
All of this is troubling, because I do not understand how we can have a broad-based economic recovery without SMBs getting the working capital fuel they require to initiate and sustain growth. Traditionally we look to the public markets to give us long-run economic visibility, despite the fact that the majority of our GDP is generated by small and midsize businesses. When you look at large corporations, you see a fairly rosy picture. There is more cash on large corporate balance sheets probably than ever in the recorded history of business. Earnings forecasts are still predicting growth in various sectors. But if things are so rosy, why are so many corporations pushing out their receivable terms out from 30, 45, 60 and sometimes 90 days?
And then there is, of course, the sticky issue of unemployment, which is around 10 percent, artificially low because it doesn’t take into account the "under-employed," nor the fact that, on a trailing basis, it has been suppressed by immense census hiring, which is now coming to an end. If the economy is going to grow, someone has to explain to me where the demand is going to come from, because the unemployment figures tell a different story. What’s more, the stimulus is running out. We are running on fumes, and the well, while not dry exactly, just ain’t as deep as it used to be. So the general intuition is, let’s not push it too far, lest the golden goose stop providing.
And lastly, the baby boomers are about to be saddled with a 20 to 40% increase on their dividends and interest payments next year, no doubt a significant portion of their disposable income, and smack in the midst of their transformation from net savers to net spenders. This coming increase is being referred to as the "Tax Wall," and it could force the baby boomers to curb their spending.
So here’s what we have: tight credit for the SMB economic engine, a poor employment environment, shrinking stimulus-generated economic growth, and the promise of decreasing consumption from arguably the largest consumption engine of our economy – the baby boomers. Normally I would look for an opportunity amidst the ongoing crisis, but I am suspending my contrarian tendencies. Sometimes when times are scary, it is smart to be scared.
Nic Perkin is co-founder and president of The Receivables Exchange, an accounts receivable financing tool. The Exchange is the world's first online marketplace for real-time trading of accounts receivable. Find out how to trade accounts receivable.